Murder Mystery (Case Number 1)

Case Number 1:  The Case of the Red Butterfly



A woman's voice suddenly shouts "Bill, don't kill me!"

In a quick second a gun shot is heard reverberating down the halls in the apartment complex.

A detective, upon hearing that his client has screamed, ran up the stairs (two to be precise) and came across his red haired client on the floor.

Several people stood next the dead body and a old magnum colored in crimson blood.

There was a mailman, a doctor, a teacher, a young child with her mother, and a elderly women in her late 70's shocked to find their neighbor dead.

The detective immediately knew who the culprit was.

He deduced the fact that one of these people must be the killer because:

1) When the detective reached the top floor, the killer couldn't escape through a window nor through any other room since all the rooms were apparently locked.

2) The killer couldn't escape through the stairs because the stairs the detective used is the only one that is in the building.

3) The killer definitely didn't use the elevator since the elevator today is inoperable.

4) The killer can't use the gun apparently because all the bullets were used to kill the women.

The detective summons the mailman.

"Come here sir, you're under arrest for the murder of Ms. Annie Butterfly."

The detective handcuffs the mailman and takes him into the police station.



Here's the mystery you must solve...



How did the detective know it was the mailman without thinking twice on the culprit and why?

Author's Notes/Comments: 

I'll have more murder mystery cases posted up soon...  By the way, the clues are simple than you think they are...  It's right under your 'nose.'  There are two important clues that'll help you solve the answer.  The others may help although it won't help you as much if you don't know those two crucial clues...Good luck!  /  Ok, after waiting for sometime, here's the two crucial clues you needed to solve the case:  "Mail(man) and the name Bill."  Think about it.  How did the Detective know it was the mailman?  Ok, so we know that there was an elderly women and a mother and her daughter.  Those three were all women.  But what of the other two?  The doctor and the teacher?  Let's assume for the time being that they too were also women.  So if they were all women, what is the mail(man).  Hah!  Get it?  The mailman was the only guy during the crime scene.  And duh, his name is Bill, a man's name Ms. Butterfuly screamed out before she died.  What a brainer, don't you agree?  I'll have MORE coming soon everybody.  Get those detective caps because these cases will keep coming...

View bluewave's Full Portfolio
Bryan Adam Tomimbang's picture

Case solved! Hard but I found it! LOL! - Kevin